Expert Experiments

Same numbers, different stories

Four data sets share every summary statistic. Graph them and they tell four different stories.

About 20 min Pen and paper Log in to save your work

Four lab groups measured how a quantity \(y\) depends on a setting \(x\). All four handed in the same summary: mean \(y = 7.50\), best line \(y = 0.500\,x + 3.00\), \(R^2 = 0.67\). Did they find the same thing?

Data table The four data sets

Groups A to C used the same settings x; group D used its own, xD.

Loading…
Group A: mean y
–
Group B: mean y
–
Group C: mean y
–
Group D: mean y
–
Q1

Same means, same line, same \(R^2\). What will the four graphs look like?

not graded
Commit to a prediction to see the graphs.

Graph them

Graph Group A
Loading…
Graph Group B
Loading…
Graph Group C
Loading…
Graph Group D
Loading…

Match the story

Q2

Which group's data follow a smooth curve, not a line?

1 pt
Q3

Which group has one reading that is probably a copying or measuring mistake?

1 pt
Q4

Which group barely varied the setting it was testing?

1 pt
Q5

Which group's line is a fair summary of its data?

1 pt

Fix the analysis

Q6

Above group B's graph, switch the fit to Parabola. What is \(R^2\) now?

1 pt
Q7

In the table, delete group C's suspicious value (\(y_C = 12.74\) in row 3). What slope \(k\) does group C's line have now?

1 pt
Q8

Group D claims: “\(y\) grows with \(x\), with slope 0.5.” Do you agree? Give a claim, evidence from the graph, and your reasoning.

2 pts

The statistician Frank Anscombe built these four data sets in 1973 to make one point: graph your data before you trust any number calculated from it.

Habit to keep: graph first. Means, fits and \(R^2\) come after you've seen the shape.